This is wonderful.
Friday, 10 April 2020
Thursday, 9 April 2020
When the Predictable Happens
I have been looking at the progress of Coronavirus, firstly in China and then elsewhere, since January this year. I've felt for some time that the Government has been responding slowly - from early March onwards, in fact - and I personally started fairly rigorous social distancing on the 12th.
Also I have a lung condition - one that is not that common (sarcoids) - so I was aware that I was at risk.
Plotting the figures, I could predict that numbers contracting the virus and the numbers of those dying would go up exponentially - just as they did elsewhere.
However, it is all now happening (broadly as I expected). And it is scary. The relatively high numbers of deaths at present are roughly as anticipated, but that doesn't make it any easier to watch.
Also, I've had a letter from King's, a text from the Government, and a call from my Consultant, all telling me I'm at risk and that I should be 'shielding'. And despite expecting all of this, it has been quite upsetting.
So being proven right gives no solace, and really didn't help me prepare emotionally - or rather, it was an opportunity that I failed to make use of.
Hey-ho...
Also I have a lung condition - one that is not that common (sarcoids) - so I was aware that I was at risk.
Plotting the figures, I could predict that numbers contracting the virus and the numbers of those dying would go up exponentially - just as they did elsewhere.
However, it is all now happening (broadly as I expected). And it is scary. The relatively high numbers of deaths at present are roughly as anticipated, but that doesn't make it any easier to watch.
Also, I've had a letter from King's, a text from the Government, and a call from my Consultant, all telling me I'm at risk and that I should be 'shielding'. And despite expecting all of this, it has been quite upsetting.
So being proven right gives no solace, and really didn't help me prepare emotionally - or rather, it was an opportunity that I failed to make use of.
Hey-ho...
Sunday, 29 March 2020
Wednesday, 25 March 2020
The Poetry is in the Pity
More from the book pile
The War Poems,
Siegfried Sassoon, (Faber, 1983), edited by Rupert Hart-Davis.
Sassoon was one of
the War Poets who actually survived the First World War, despite being wounded
several times. His Wikipedia entry is very
interesting (including his coaching and encouragement of Wilfrid Owen and the
fact that he used to play cricket with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle!), and provides
useful context for these poems.
The book is a rather elegant, if somewhat austere
collection. Hart-Davis brings together
all of Sassoon’s wartime poems, including those published at the time and
several which only survived in manuscript form, and presents them with minimal notes
in the (best-guess) order in which they were composed. He also includes a few post-War poems which take
the War as their subject. There is a
brief and rather dry chronology of Sassoon’s life to create a sparse framework
for the poems – it is possible to see which were composed in the trenches and
which were created when he was in England, convalescing.
What emerges, slowly, is a story of a man who enlisted
willingly and early on in the conflict, full of patriotism and a belief that he
was doing the right thing for Country and God, but who, as he witnessed and suffered
the horrors of war slowly shifted his position, eventually condemning those who
led the War as well as those who eloquently supported it while staying at home.
The poems in the middle section in particular constitute a complex recounting
of the brutal experiences in the trenches.
There is a significant sense of tough realism to the poems,
which meant that several of them couldn’t be published while the War was happening. He speaks several times of the happiness that
the soldiers felt if they received a ‘Blighty wound’ – bad enough to
incapacitate them and get them sent back to England, but not killing them. (‘Splendid
to eat and sleep and choose a wife/Safe with his wound, a citizen of life’ – ‘The
One-Legged Man’, 1916). And of the men
who would sometimes manufacture such wounds for themselves. He writes of rotting corpses and the arbitrariness
of death, and the wretched reality of living in the trenches for months at a
time.
Sassoon was an officer, and in combat was renowned for his
almost suicidal bravery (his men called him ‘Mad Jack’). He won several awards
for bravery. But finally he realised he
hated leading his young troops towards the enemy, and seeing them cut
down. In 1917 he wrote a statement
against the continuation of the War, ‘Finished with the War: A Soldier’s
Declaration,’ which was read out in the House of Commons. This led to him being shunted out of the way
to the Craiglockhart War Hospital to be treated – ostensibly – for shell-shock. Although he did eventually return to the
front.
Admittedly, none of the individual poems shines quite like,
say Owens’ ‘Dulce et Decorum Est,’ but the collection as a whole has a layered,
rich quality that works differently, and the whole cycle (if they can be called
that) has quite a powerful effect.
I’ll include one here (picked almost at random).
Suicide in the Trenches
I knew a simple soldier boy
Who grinned at life in empty joy,
Slept soundly through the lonesome dark,
And whistled early with the lark.
In winter trenches, cowed and glum,
With crumps and lice and lack of rum,
He put a bullet through his brain.
No one spoke of him again.
. . .
You smug-faced crowds with kindling eye
Who cheer when soldier lads walk by,
Sneak home and pray you’ll never know
The hell where youth and laughter go.
(Feb 1918)
Suicide in the Trenches
I knew a simple soldier boy
Who grinned at life in empty joy,
Slept soundly through the lonesome dark,
And whistled early with the lark.
In winter trenches, cowed and glum,
With crumps and lice and lack of rum,
He put a bullet through his brain.
No one spoke of him again.
. . .
You smug-faced crowds with kindling eye
Who cheer when soldier lads walk by,
Sneak home and pray you’ll never know
The hell where youth and laughter go.
(Feb 1918)
The Man Who Was Thursday
Now that we are all in (semi-) lockdown, I'm taking the opportunity to read some, at least, of my pile of unread books. It's a bit on the towering side.
I'll post commentaries here and on Mens Sana (Facebook Group).
Here's the first one.
So this isn’t just an adventure story from the early twentieth century. Chesterton’s full title for the novel gives it away, in part. It has all the logic of a mad dream.
I'll post commentaries here and on Mens Sana (Facebook Group).
Here's the first one.
Mere Anarchy
G. K. Chesterton, The Man Who
Was Thursday: A Nightmare, (1908), (Penguin Edition, with ‘Introduction’ by
Matthew Beaumont, 2011).
My, but this is an odd book.
When I chose it from the pile of
unread books, I thought I was picking a simple tale of derring-do, a ripping
yarn rather akin to The Riddle of the Sands (Childers, 1903) or The
Thirty-Nine Steps (Buchan, 1915), albeit hopefully leavened with
Chesterton’s characteristic wit. I knew
it was about secret anarchists and plots, bombings and detectives, but that was
about all I knew. And around this time,
there was a lot of fiction, and nonfiction concerning anarchists being written.
The Spirit of Revolt (Kropotkin,
1880), The Dynamiter (Stevenson, 1885), The Science of Revolutionary
Warfare: A Little Handbook of Instruction in the Use and Preparation of
Nitroglycerine, Gun-Cotton, Fulminating Mercury, Bombs, Fuses, Potions, Etc,
Etc (Most, 1885), The League of Twelve (Boothby, 1903), A Girl
Among the Anarchists (Olivia and Helen Rossetti, 1903) and The Secret Agent (Conrad, 1907) are all
mentioned in the critical apparatus in the book.
Nobel had patented dynamite in 1866 (first
demonstrated in Redhill) and gelignite in 1876.
In 1893, the Chamber of Deputies in Paris was bombed; in 1894 there was
an unsuccessful bomb attack on the Royal Observatory in Greenwich, and
separately the French President was assassinated; in 1897 the Spanish prime
minister was assassinated; in 1900 the King of Italy was assassinated; in 1906
there was a failed attempt to bomb the King of Spain; and in the month Chesterton’s book was
published the King of Portugal and his son were assassinated. Bombs, revolutions, assassinations and
anarchists were on everyone’s minds.
And there is a plot, a story
which revolves around all of this material, as a detective/poet attempts to
thwart an anarchist plot to bomb the Czar and the President of France, in
Paris. It is a plot concerning the fight
between order and anarchy, as conducted by a brave individual. But it is such an extreme, madcap, ridiculous
plot that you end up coming to the conclusion that it isn’t really the
point.
Partly this is because it is
written by Chesterton. As such, the book
is full of witty observations, paradoxes and inversions.
“All the same,” replied Syme
patiently, “just at present you only see the tree by the light of the
lamp. I wonder when you would ever see
the lamp by the light of the tree.” (p.8).
The paradoxes are even there in some of the chapter titles (11: ‘The Criminals Chase the Police’). And while some of the observations feel
hopelessly dated, many still seem quite fresh over a century later interesting
– such as when he speaks of the uncanny feeling one gets at a waxworks (p.39) –
an early example of the ‘Uncanny Valley’?
Chesterton is also very good on
small details and the quotidian. He
wants to describe everything, even the most mundane item. He cares about the wonderfulness of the
everyday, the banal ordinary. As when
the hero is inspired to courage by the sound of a simple, common barrel organ
in Leicester Square.
At the same time, his abiding
interest in the grotesque is ever-present.
Every one of the anarchists has odd, weird traits, unlikely facial
expressions and tics. None just look
normal or unremarkable.
So, in one sense this novel is
Chesterton’s version of Browning’s dramatic monologues (see Men and Women
(1855), Dramatis Personae (1864) and many other individual poems). And of course, he had written his excellent
book on the poet in 1903, praising his grotesqueries and his interest in the
quotidian, while arguing that these were also routes to the spiritual (I
paraphrase).
Amongst the grotesques the huge
figure of the President of the anarchists stands out. And as Chesterton himself was a large man,
one begins by assuming that this is a self-portrait. After all the President sets much of the plot
in action and is feared by all the others; an obvious author-substitute. However, by the end one realises this is
probably not the case. Or not just the
case.
Because the end is quite
unexpected. If the story is so extreme
and the characters so unlikely, that they undermine the whole notion of the
adventure-narrative, and also play against Chesterton’s fine details and
interest in the ordinary, which I would contend they do, then the conclusion of
the novel takes another yet turn to the unexpected.
It goes all mythic and
transcendent. Arguably this may have
been the only place left for Chesterton’s madcap narrative to go, but it still
comes as a surprise. Without saying too
much, it goes supernatural and religious, and there are some interesting
proto-surrealist touches.
…a vast carnival of people were dancing in motley dress. Syme seemed to see every shape in Nature imitated in some crazy costume. There was a man dressed as a windmill with enormous sails, a man dressed as an elephant, a man dressed as a balloon… one dancer dressed like an enormous hornbill, with a beak twice as big as itself…(p.152)
For Chesterton, nonsense was a
type of writing replete with spiritual significance, because it so effectively
communicates a sense of amazement at the ‘huge and undecipherable unreason’ of
life itself. (Chesterton, The Defendant, (1901), taken from Beaumont’s
‘Introduction’).
So this isn’t just an adventure story from the early twentieth century. Chesterton’s full title for the novel gives it away, in part. It has all the logic of a mad dream.
And it is a page-turner, but what
those pages turn up is just not what you might expect.
Labels:
Coronavirus,
G. K. Chesterton,
London,
Middle England,
Paris,
Review
Monday, 23 March 2020
The Last Few Weeks in Pictures
We are all currently in social distancing, sensible lockdown. A lot has been happening. In no particular order, here are some of the events here at Trees, in the last few weeks, in pictures.
Welcome to my world...
Welcome to my world...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


















